How to Keep Your Health Plan Costs Manageable — Without Shortchanging Your Team

When you run a enterprise, there’s a well-known electronic mail you most likely opened this fall: the one out of your advantages dealer along with your 2026 medical insurance renewal.

You scroll. You see a double-digit improve, and your abdomen drops. You wish to do proper by your group. You even have a P&L to guard. And the three customary choices you’re handed — pay the rise, increase deductibles or push extra price onto staff — all really feel unhealthy in numerous methods.

Over the past 5 years of constructing and scaling my firm, I’ve lived that renewal assembly many occasions. Our headcount grew from a couple of dozen individuals to greater than 100. At occasions, our brokers introduced us quotes that had been shockingly excessive. We pushed again, redesigned plans and tried to stability three realities:

Prices are going by the roof.We wish our individuals to really feel genuinely supported.We can not take up each improve with out penalties elsewhere within the enterprise.

This isn’t authorized or actuarial recommendation. I’m not a advantages guide. I’m a founder who has needed to signal the renewal after which look my staff within the eyes. That is the playbook we’ve developed — one which any employer can adapt as you roll out your 2026 protection and begin getting ready for 2027.

1. Get sincere concerning the three levers you actually management

While you strip away the jargon, most mid-sized employers have three major levers:

Employer contribution: what share of the premium you pay versus your employeesPlan design: deductibles, out-of-pocket maximums, co-pays and community structureCommunication: how clearly you clarify what all of this implies in actual life

In our early renewals, I targeted far an excessive amount of on the primary two and never practically sufficient on the third. It’s tempting to deal with medical insurance like a procurement train: push the dealer to buy carriers, negotiate the rise down, tweak deductibles and co-pays, signal and transfer on.

The issue is that your group solely experiences the plan on the physician’s workplace, pharmacy or ER — not in a spreadsheet. When you don’t clarify the tradeoffs upfront, individuals will really feel blindsided later.

Now, after we have a look at a renewal, we begin with three questions:

What can the enterprise realistically take up this yr?What is going to our individuals really feel on the level of care — in {dollars}, not percentages?How are we going to inform that story in plain language?

When you can’t reply all three, you’re not able to signal.

2. Present your group the true numbers, not simply the brand new card

Even “good” plans include actual out-of-pocket prices. A typical household can simply face hundreds of {dollars} in deductibles and coinsurance earlier than hitting the out-of-pocket most. For somebody who’s additionally lacking work and juggling childcare and transportation, that’s not a line merchandise — it’s a disaster.

As leaders, we frequently underestimate how complicated that is. We are saying “$2,500 deductible” and assume individuals know what which means in the course of a annoying medical scenario.

One easy change that’s helped us:

We turned the dense advantages booklet right into a one-page explainer written in plain language:

What a deductible is and the way a lot really comes out of pocket on the level of careWhat coinsurance means utilizing an actual instance (e.g., “If in case you have a $5,000 surgical procedure, right here’s roughly what you’d owe below every plan choice.”)What the out-of-pocket most is and why it issues

We stroll by that one-pager throughout open enrollment and provides managers speaking factors. The objective isn’t to show supervisors into advantages specialists. It’s to take away the shock issue, so an worker isn’t studying about deductibles for the primary time whereas sitting in a hospital robe.

Over time, we’ve additionally needed to acknowledge a tough reality: we’re doing extra as an organization — our whole spend has gone up — and staff are nonetheless paying greater than they did 5 years in the past. Naming that truthfully has constructed belief. Folks might not love the reply, however they recognize the realness.

3. Supply first-dollar assist the place it issues most

When you can’t take up the complete improve (most of us can’t), you continue to have choices apart from “good luck with the deductible.”

Take into consideration first-dollar publicity — the money your individuals should provide you with earlier than insurance coverage actually begins serving to. There are a couple of focused methods to melt that influence:

Small emergency-expense help: Some employers supply a modest emergency profit or hardship fund for real crises — to not cowl each invoice, however to bridge the worst moments.Voluntary supplemental protection: Accident, hospital indemnity and comparable merchandise will help staff who need additional safety by a small payroll deduction.A normal hardship script: We’ve given managers steering on what they will and may’t promise, and the place to ship somebody who’s clearly in monetary misery.

The purpose is to not turn into a financial institution. The purpose is to acknowledge that the primary $500–$2,000 of an sudden medical occasion is commonly essentially the most painful — and to resolve, as a management group, what you’re keen and capable of do about it.

4. Assist individuals navigate complicated payments (with out changing into their claims division)

Even when you supply a stable plan, individuals can nonetheless get hit with medical payments that make no sense.

A number of years in the past, somebody in my household had a routine process. We did every part “proper”: checked that the surgeon and hospital had been in-network and confirmed it prematurely. Weeks later, an out-of-network anesthesia group we’d by no means heard of despatched a invoice that was roughly ten occasions what we anticipated. It took years of back-and-forth to resolve.

If that’s complicated for somebody who works within the insurance coverage ecosystem, think about the way it feels on your common worker.

You don’t have to repair each declare personally, however you’ll be able to:

Create a easy dispute playbook:

Align intently along with your dealer (and TPA when you’re self-funded):

Make certain there’s a single, clear escalation pathKnow who on the dealer’s workplace is accountable for resolving the ugliest claims — and maintain them to it

The objective isn’t to vow that each invoice will go away. It’s to verify your individuals don’t really feel fully alone once they get one they don’t perceive.

5. Deal with renewal as a nine-month course of, not a nine-day scramble

Most employers deal with renewal as a season. Your dealer sends choices, you react, decide, announce it and transfer on till subsequent yr.

In observe, the selections you make now are formed by what you probably did — or didn’t do — over the prior yr.

A number of methods to get forward:

Seize a five-year story, not simply this yr’s quote. Ask your finance or HR lead (or, in our case, our head of advantages) to summarize:

Preliminary improve versus last negotiated improve every yearHow deductibles, out-of-pocket maximums and employer contributions have changedMajor shifts in utilization (e.g., ER visits versus pressing care)

Seeing that trendline in a single place adjustments the dialog from “Can we survive this yr?” to “What are we constructing towards?”

Determine your non-negotiables prematurely. For us, which may appear to be: “We gained’t drop our employer contribution beneath X% on the bottom plan,” or “We gained’t increase the deductible greater than Y in a single yr.” Your numbers will differ. What issues is deciding earlier than you’re below stress.

Know when to think about self-funding. We’re nonetheless on a standard, absolutely insured plan. Many advisors recommend that when you attain 150–200 staff, self-funding or captives may be value exploring, with stop-loss protection above a sure threshold. When you’re approaching that measurement, begin the dialog early so that you’re not making a structural change in a panic.

6. Keep in mind: medical insurance is a human downside first

It’s straightforward to speak about medical insurance like a spreadsheet downside — premiums, development traces, loss ratios. However for workers, it exhibits up as a late-night urgent-care go to with a sick baby, a shock invoice after surgical procedure or a partner who all of a sudden can’t work.

As founders and enterprise leaders, we will’t repair the complete system. However we will do three issues:

Make intentional, clear selections about what we’re providing.Clarify these selections in language individuals can really perceive.Put easy playbooks in place so the worst moments are much less chaotic.

Do this, and also you gained’t simply “get by” renewal season. You’ll flip it into one thing rarer: a second the place individuals can see that you simply took their actual lives into consideration earlier than you signed on the dotted line.

Join the Entrepreneur Each day e-newsletter to get the information and sources it’s essential know right now that will help you run your online business higher. Get it in your inbox.

When you run a enterprise, there’s a well-known electronic mail you most likely opened this fall: the one out of your advantages dealer along with your 2026 medical insurance renewal.

You scroll. You see a double-digit improve, and your abdomen drops. You wish to do proper by your group. You even have a P&L to guard. And the three customary choices you’re handed — pay the rise, increase deductibles or push extra price onto staff — all really feel unhealthy in numerous methods.